You are currently browsing the monthly archive for April 2014.
Catching up this week with some of the things from last week’s UKSG conference so I’ve been viewing some of the presentations that have been put up on YouTube at https://www.youtube.com/user/UKSGLIVE There were a few that were of particular interest, especially those covering the Discovery strand.
The one that really got my attention was from Simone Kortekaas from Utrecht University talking about their decision to move away from discovery by shutting down their own in-house developed search system and now looking at shutting down their WebOPAC. The presentation is embedded below
I found it interesting to work through the process that they went through, from realising that most users were starting their search elsewhere than the library (mainly Google Scholar) and so deciding to focus on making it easier for users to access library content through that route, instead of trying to focus on getting users to come to the library, to a library search tool. It recognises that other players (i.e. the big search engines) may do discovery better than libraries.
I think I’d agree with the principle that libraries need to be where there users are. So providing holdings to Google Scholar so the ‘find it at your library’ feature works and providing bookmarklet tools (e.g. http://www.open.ac.uk/library/new-tools/live-tools) to help users login are all important things to do. But whilst Google and Bing now seem to be better at finding academic content they still lack Google Scholar’s ‘Library links’ feature and the ability to upload your holdings that would allow you to offer the same form of ‘Find it at the…’ feature in those spaces. And with Google Scholar you always worry about how ‘mainstream’ it is considered.
It is an interesting direction to take as a strategic decision and means that you need to carefully monitor (as Utrecht do) trends in user activity and in particular changes in those major search engines to make sure that your resources can be found through major search engines. One consequence is that users are largely being taken to publisher websites to access the content and we know that the variations in these sites can cause users some difficulty/confusion. But it’s an approach to think about as we see where the trend for discovery takes us.